Honor Blog Preview

Today is: Jun 24, 2018
Post From: May 28, 2018

The Immorality of Virtue Signalling

Today we are going to discuss the concept of "virtue signalling". I suspect most of you have encountered that phrase before - but to make sure we are all on the same page, let's use this definition: Virtue signalling occurs when a person states or supports an opinion in order to maintain a good and moral appearance.

An essential nuance to this definition is suggested by the word "appearance". The implication here is that the virtue signaller is not bearing any of the costs associated with the opinion or position. So, for example, if you are out walking around your neighborhood, and you see a yard which is covered in dandelions, and you say "that person should clean up his yard" - you are virtue signalling.

Worth noting is that, generally, the signaled opinion is correct - that person should clean up his yard. At the level of an observation, it is very hard to argue with the virtues which are signalled.

However, it also is essential to recognize that the person doing the signalling is not bearing the costs associated with his or her opinion. Yes, the homeowner should clean up the dandelions. But what if he was sent away on business? What if it has rained every time he has scheduled time to do that work? What if he lost his job and cannot afford to buy the bags of stuff which would limit the dandelions? What if he has been spending days at the hospital with his sick wife?

The difference between virtue and virtue signalling lies in the acceptance of the costs: if you wish to be virtuous, you must accept the costs of a decision.

This brings us to housing in Seattle. (Didn't see that transition coming, did you?) You see, Seattle recognizes that people with criminal histories often have trouble recovering from that past - finding jobs and housing is more difficult for those who have a criminal record, and those additional challenges contribute to recidivism. To address that problem, Seattle has passed a Fair Chance Housing Ordinance. This law prevents potential landlords from checking the criminal histories of prospective tenants. The idea is to eliminate discrimination, so that people with criminal convictions who have served their time will not face discrimination as they try to re-build their lives.

The virtuous opinion seems pretty clear - good people are opposed to discrimination, and we all want to help people recover from bad episodes in their lives. Thus it seems reasonable to support laws which enforce non-discrimination.

However, consider the situation of a small-business landlord - a person who owns one or two units for rent. This person cannot afford large amounts of insurance, major repair bills, and certainly cannot accept the risk of large legal fees. What that Fair Chance Housing Ordinance does is deny landlords the ability to manage their risk, to protect themselves against the additional costs which are likely to accompany the granting of housing to potential criminals.

Indeed, this article (reference below) describes exactly that conflict and carries it one step farther, to the situation of MariLyn and Chong Yim, who actually live in one of the units of a tri-plex - renting out the other two. What the Fair Chance Housing Ordinance means is that the Yims, who have young children, may be legally required to rent to potential criminals, exposing their young children to elements of society they might not want their children to see.

Clearly, the people who have passed the Fair Chance Housing Ordinance are not recognizing the full costs of their political opinions. They are imposing a decision on others (the Yims) without bearing the costs themselves - they are "virtue signalling", because they do not face the consequences of their opinions.

It should be clear that this is immoral - that this is not an honorable thing to do. It is morally wrong for the city of Seattle to strip landlords of the ability to protect themselves and their families from physical threats, not to mention the business threats faced by small-business landlords.

This is true of a great many decisions made by government. As I discuss in my book, collective action always requires careful moral reflection, because it ALWAYS compromises the freedom of members. This example reveals the power of that difficulty - government gives some citizens the ability to force others to bear the consequences of their beliefs.

Stated another way, government is the perfect vehicle for virtue signalling - for creating the appearance of virtue without bearing its costs.

References

Blevins, Ethan. Smug Seattle to mom and pop landlords: Criminals are welcome! Your rights not so much. Fox News, May 21, 2018.
URL: http://www.foxnews.com/opinion/2018/05/21/smug-seattle-to-mom-and-pop-landlords-criminals-are-welcome-your-rights-not-so-much.html

Read more at The Honor Blog.

About Charlie Collins

Charlie Dressed Nice

Dr. Collins received his Bachelor of Science in Physics from the College of William and Mary in 1989, graduating Phi Beta Kappa and Magna Cum Laude. He went on to pursue a doctoral degree in Physics at MIT, with a focus on Theoretical Astrophysics, receiving his diploma in 1996.

To begin his professional career, Dr. Collins went to work for ACI Worldwide, a software company best known for its on-line transaction-processing products. There he performed a variety of technical and market research functions. Upon leaving ACI, he re-connected with the field of education, first spending a year at his high-school alma mater (Mt. Michael Benedictine in Elkhorn, Nebraska), then spending twelve years teaching information technology at a local college. Currently, Dr. Collins serves on the faculty at Duchesne Academy of the Sacred Heart, where he teaches Mathematics.

In addition to those endeavors, Dr. Collins spends as much time as he is able pursuing a variety of writing projects. Many of those are reflected in these pages: Take a look at the Books and Publishing page for information about the fantasy trilogy The Roc and the Griffon, as well as for work which is under development. In particular, please look for information about Reawakening Honor - not only is this book worth learning about in its own right, but Dr. Collins hopes to use it as a way to experiment with alternative approaches toward publishing.

About Creative Impulse

Creative Impulse is a very small (microscopic) publisher located in Omaha, Nebraska. True to its name, the company works in a variety of creative areas - web design and development, speculative fiction, and a little bit of philosophical discussion. Feel free to explore the site and learn more.

Contact information:

Creative Impulse
7004 Farnam St. Suite 101
Omaha, Nebraska 68132
questions@creativeimpulse.biz